I really like that aspect of tanking not being rewarded in OOTP. It is realistic because if you tank in real life you create such a culture of losing that it just destroys the hopes and dreams of even your best prospects. It takes years and years of trying to claw your way out of that loathsome trog-hole and redefine your identity. When I started playing OOTP I made the decision to field the best lineup I could every year and never tank. I assumed it would take at least 4 years to build that non-loser identity. I stacked my minor league teams with 28 year old washed up WBL players as ringers so that at least the YOUTHS would learn a culture of winning! That's why even on losing teams I resisted trading away my good players until I felt like I could get more than fair future value out of them while also providing adequate replacement coverage for the position they vacated.
Yankee turned his team into the Oakland Raiders, basically. A proud franchise goes from a super bowl appearance to suffering through decades of loathsome performance as that culture of losing clings to them. During that losing time period they've actually had a ton of talent on the roster too, they just didn't believe they could win.
I'll use the Tim Tebow example again to explain why he was one of the best first round draft picks Denver ever made simply because of his TALISMAN powers. I don't give a shit about his lack of talent, he believed he'd win and he got the entire team to believe they'd win as well. He took a team that had a culture of losing (from McDaniels and Orton) and transformed them to a team that could win even WITH his shitty QB play. That's ultimately what drew Peyton to Denver too. He realized that if the team went to the playoffs with Shitty Tebow playing, they could be really good with competent QB play. Now that Manning is so old and terrible, he's similarly just riding the culture of winning despite the fact that he's playing terrible.
I was hoping CICIO would be the type of Talisman that could help the rest of Yankee's pitchers discover the BABIP cheat, but it just hasn't worked that way. Instead, CICIO has been infected by Yankee's toxic clubhouse and his BABIP has now reached failure levels.
I think what Yankee needs is just many more Talismanic creatures. Fortunately for him, I have a plentiful supply of Talismans.