All trolling aside, here are my thoughts on OSU. They reasonably cannot get in ahead of PSU. Didn't win their division, didn't win the H2H, and didn't win the conference. If the B1G was really such hot shit as B1G fans claim, you almost have to let PSU in for winning it.
Bama, and to a lesser extent Clemson, are givens.
That leaves UW. UW has a weaker best win (Colorado?), a worse loss (home throttling by USC), and a horrendous OOC schedule (Rutgers, Portland State, and Idaho? That should be illegal). OSU is significantly better on all three of those comps (less so OOC, but OU is a good win).
So what it boils down to is does the committee leave out a P5 champion in favor of a team with an identical record that didn't even win its division?
EDIT- I am not sure these dudes aren't influenced by the regional distribution of teams, too. If the furthest-west team is based in Tuscaloosa, that's a whole lot of people (3? time zones' worth) who just won't tune in, given that these are New Year's Eve games and will be hurting for viewers enough as it is.
Bama, and to a lesser extent Clemson, are givens.
That leaves UW. UW has a weaker best win (Colorado?), a worse loss (home throttling by USC), and a horrendous OOC schedule (Rutgers, Portland State, and Idaho? That should be illegal). OSU is significantly better on all three of those comps (less so OOC, but OU is a good win).
So what it boils down to is does the committee leave out a P5 champion in favor of a team with an identical record that didn't even win its division?
EDIT- I am not sure these dudes aren't influenced by the regional distribution of teams, too. If the furthest-west team is based in Tuscaloosa, that's a whole lot of people (3? time zones' worth) who just won't tune in, given that these are New Year's Eve games and will be hurting for viewers enough as it is.
Last edited: