I think I might have missed this at some point, but what do the playoffs look like at this point in time? Still that goofy setup you had to start with that limited it to like 1 district spot and lots of good teams competing for it? When does "grade inflation" strike the Florida High School footbaw so that 4 win teams make the playoffs?
At this stage of the dynasty the playoffs structure consists of classifications with either 8 or 16 districts. Each district will have between 3 or I've seen as many as 8 teams. Teams play round robin style with the best record getting one playoff spot. 3 way or more ties are settled with a Kansas tiebreaker playoff usually the Monday night before the 1st round of the playoffs.
The goofy stuff was through 1974. You could have districts with 12 to 14 teams. There was no way for every team to play each other so there wasn't really any attempt to play many teams in your district, other than those in your local area. For instance Astronaut's district in 1974 had a team from Ocala which is a two hour drive away. The way the district champion was decided was based on a point system for wins which varied on the class of the team you beat (4 points for beating a lower class team, 10 points for beating a higher or same class team). They also had a rule that you got zero points for a loss. You only counted 8 games in your point total, and you had to count all losses. So if you were 9-1, you only got points for 7 of your best wins, 8-2, 6 wins, and so on. This setup allowed for teams that were 10-0 to be left out of the playoffs, and we saw that earlier. In 1975 the current setup began where you had to play all the teams in your district.
This setup would go until I think 1992 or 1993. At that point they added a round to the playoffs and allowed district runner ups in. The district champ got a first round home game and the runner up played on the road. Whenever a champ played a runner up in later rounds the champ would host. I think in around 1999 or 2000 they lowered the number of classes, say from 16 to 12. Gave 24 playoff spots for champs and runners up, and then had 8 at large teams, two in each quadrant or region. This allowed for a good team in a stacked district that finished 3rd to get in the playoffs. I'm not sure at what point they went back to the pure champ/runnerup model that exists today. But if we take this dynasty far enough we will find out!
You may have also had the phenomenon of this at large system creating some "grade inflation" as you say and allowing some 6-4, 5-5 teams in. I remember at one point I think it was 2001 or 2002 I traveled up to Jacksonville as Astronaut played Bishop Kenney in the first round and they were a 6-4 team. Astronaut was a runner up and Kenny was a district champ, or it was at-large vs. runner up, idk.
In the late 80's Live Oak Suwannee won 4 consecutive state titles I think. One of the years they were something like 4-6 in the regular season with all of their wins district wins. They only had to win 3 playoff games to win state and they did. So they were state champs with a 7-6 record. There may have been some forfeits among those 6 losses for an ineligible player but I'm not sure.
At this part of the dynasty it really is a situation where the Astronaut -Titusville season finale winner goes to the playoffs. Astronaut made the playoffs 6 times from 1972 to 1986. If they had the runner up model in place at that time they would have had 5 to 7 more playoff appearances (depending on what would have been Kansas tiebreaker outcomes). Titusville had 6 playoff appearances as well. I really wonder what this would have looked like if they never split the schools up in 1972. They would have had enrollments form 2500 to 3000, but there are big schools in Orlando and Miami and Jacksoville that have those enrollments. Maybe they wouldn't have been able to compete with those levels. We'll never know. Unless we do another re-enactment dynasty based on a combined school...(wheels turning...)