Choosing formations should really be to create situations you want. I completely agree with some of the earlier posts about wanting to set up certain strengths with your formation. The idea is that by recognizing the strengths and weaknesses of each formation, you can better decide what looks...
I used a play call sheet back in the day. I unfortunately lost the file and can't remember much. I do know I had sections for 3rd & short, 3rd & long, red zone, goal line, backed up offense. Basic situational football ideas that I picked up from reading the following link...
I unfortunately did not see anything related to the BSCFL over there. I'm amazed this OD actually carried on for as long as it did. BoilerScott would be proud if he were still alive today.
As for the direction of the BSCFL? I call for a glorious reboot come release of the next NCAA domo...